I've been seeing a lot of talk lately about objectively reviewing whether renting or buying is best for your financial situation. While pretty confident in my choice to purchase, I wanted to run the numbers just in case.
------
BEFORE
------
Rental
900 sf
$650 per month for rent
$ 75 per month for storage building
$200 per month average gas & electric
------
$925 per month
------
AFTER
------
Owned Home
1800 sf
$493 per month for mortgage
$--- per month PMI (not required for our loan)
$ 55 per month for homeowner's
$ 55 per month for property taxes
$100 per month average electric
------
$703
OK, so right off the top I'm saving $222 per month. Interestingly enough, that is exactly equal to the 6% of my gross salary I set aside for retirement, but I digress...
------
MONEY INVESTED IN THE HOUSE
------
$4246 5% down, half of closing costs
$2600 tree removal (bought knowing this was needed)
$ 350 dishwasher and drain pipe replacement
$ 500 various vixture & outlet replacements
------
$ 7696
$59600 owed on mortgage
------
$67296
------
CURRENT TAX ACCESSOR'S VALUE
------
$72000
------
CURRENT ZILLOW VALUE
------
$91000
So at this point I have 67k invested in a house that I could turn around and sell for 75-80k after 9 months of ownership, plus I'm saving $222 per month in 'operating costs'.
As a side note, the tax accessor's value was 56k and the appraised value was 75k when we bought last July. The house was assessed at 56k in '01 and jumped to 72k in '06, a 28% increase in 5 years.
We intend to refinance this fall with my credit union, getting a better interest rate and pulling approximately 10k in equity out of the house. At that point we will upgrage the heat and air system, put a new roof on the den (an addition from the 60s), and possibly update the kitchen and bathrooms. If we hold it another 5 years, we should be able to about double our money...
OK, I feel better now!
Housing: Why I Bought
March 22nd, 2007 at 02:08 pm
March 22nd, 2007 at 02:27 pm 1174573643
Our electric/gas is far less though we are home 24/7 with 4 people vs. the apartment we were only home occasional nights and weekends - 2 people.
Since our house is new it has needed about nothing in repairs and maintenance. I have too many friends renting who are expected to upkeep the home and the appliances and such. They pay far more. Just thought it was interesting since you were another example your costs have gone down moving into a bigger space. Anyway, the assumption is we are energy hogs but quite the opposite, the house is so energy efficient it takes little to keep comfortable, uses less water, newer materials mean less repairs down the road - concrete roofs, copper plumbing, etc.
I think your house was older if I remember correctly, but still bucks the assumptions that bigger means more. I find those pretty broad assumptions.
Oh yeah and just because we bought twice as big didn't mean we ran out and filled it with furniture - hehe. Were just planning for future kids so we wouldn't have to move again. Over time bought the kids furnitrue but would have needed to regardless where we lived. Now we have room to store/keep our old non-kid stuff as well. Anyway, didn't get the impression you had to go buy a ton of furniture right out either.
March 22nd, 2007 at 02:27 pm 1174573664
March 22nd, 2007 at 02:45 pm 1174574720
and while i do intend to buy some funiture in the near future (dining room set and a living room set), these were needs at my previous rental as well and i would have bought them regardless. i got lucky that my 'ugly' hand-me-down couch actually looks perfect in the back den (think woodsy cabin), so instead of buying a new one to replace it as i would have at the previous house, i will be keeping it in the den and buying a new one for the front living room.
moi, i live in upstate south carolina, which has a very low cost of living compared to the rest of the country. with that said, my house cost about half of the average for my area because i bought older rather than new construction. also, i bought in an area that hasn't been 'revitalized' yet. it's safe and clean, just full of older residents (most the original homeowners, actually), so not all the houses have been kept in perfect condition. being 1 mile from our downtown, i anticipate my neighborhood will soon be booming. we're already seeing an influx of 'next generation buyers', which almost always increases property values. woohoo!
March 22nd, 2007 at 03:06 pm 1174575975
March 22nd, 2007 at 03:12 pm 1174576354
Sounds like you did the right thing with your house.
March 22nd, 2007 at 05:05 pm 1174583139
March 22nd, 2007 at 06:36 pm 1174588604
So to say you're saving $222 a month is a little deceiving becus your monthly cost comparison doesn't reflect the extra $4k you put into the down payment on the ownership side.
March 22nd, 2007 at 06:56 pm 1174589772
if we sold today we would make back our down payment, closing costs, money invested in the house (total of 7696) plus earn an additional $8000 or so in increased value...
March 22nd, 2007 at 07:19 pm 1174591183
March 23rd, 2007 at 03:06 am 1174619161
And as long as your mortgage is a fixed one, congrats! You got a great deal.
The problem up here in Seattle is that if anyone who can fog a mirror can get a 500K loan, it means that every house is selling for ... 500K. And most people who can fog that mirror don't really know what being 500K in debt really, really means.
March 23rd, 2007 at 01:10 pm 1174655451
March 23rd, 2007 at 01:40 pm 1174657200
ba: we haven't decided what to do with the crack shack yet DH wants to bulldoze it and pay significant money to build a new storage building back there (or a garage, which would require me to lose my back yard to a driveway, so raise your hand if you think that's going to happen). chances are we'll get his dad to help us out for a couple of weekends and we'll rehab it: tear off the siding, put up new hardy board and paint it, replace the 2 doors and windows. if i can get the water out there working, the brick beds in front are going to be turned into lettuce patches. YUM!!!
March 25th, 2007 at 08:44 pm 1174855498
May 28th, 2007 at 02:04 pm 1180361060
Stay late at night when after the lightweights go home the best deals are to be had. Here we even have auction houses selling this year's overruns from furniture manufacturers, so it isn't that you can only get antiques there. Not so, new stuff is also often available at a fraction of the price.